Yeah, I know, my title’s weak, sue me. The other one was so good, I wanted to keep that pattern.
So, I don’t know if I’m going to stick with this artifact (is that allowed?), but I’m going to use it to answer this to see if it’s a good one I would want to pursue.
So, my artifact is Birth Control.
1. How do you classify your artifact? In what groups can you place your artifact? What connections can you make to other artifacts in the group?
Classifications include: Medicine, contraception, hormone-control, Hysterectomy
Connections: Condoms, the “Morning-after Pill,” Pain-relief (such as Pamprin), Medicine
2. Identify points of similarity between your artifact and others. Then identify points of difference with other artifacts. How is it similar? How is it different?
Birth control is similar to condoms because it prevents the fertilization of an egg to create a baby. It’s different because it is the responsibility of the woman to maintain a state of no risk when taking birth control, and it does not protect against STDs.
Birth control is similar to the Morning-after Pill because it negates getting pregnant. However, the morning-after pill is a last resort, where birth control should be taken regularly.
Birth control is similar to other oral medication such as Pamprin that is take to relieve/subdue the side effects of the menstrual cycle. It is different because pain relievers such as Pamprin do not inhibit/prevent pregnancy.
Birth control is similar to a hysterectomy because it suspends the ability to get pregnant. However, birth control is temporary. Hysterectomies have adverse hormonal affects, while birth control regulates your hormones.
Birth control is similar to medicine because it comes with side effects. It’s different because medicine usually treats conditions/symptoms and is (usually) non-gendered, while birth control prevents a condition, and is only for women.
3. What metaphors or analogies suit your artifact? (Explain if needed)
Loaded die; there’s no more gambling on whether or not you’re going to get pregnant.
Life support machine; if the woman taking birth control is actively having sex, then her pills can be seen as a life support machine for her sexual affairs – if she forgets one pill, it’s like pulling the plug, and could end her life as she knows it if she gets pregnant
Flashing “Open” for business sign; people assume that if a girl is on birth control, it means she’s ready to have sex/wants to have sex/is having sex. Of course, they have to have knowledge of it – there is no way for a person to tell by looking at someone, so maybe flashing isn’t the best example….
Safety-net (obvious)
*more to come, might edit this post if I think of more*
4. How is your artifact characterized? (How do people/media/groups characterize it?)
Note: I try to represent many different perspectives under the different categories. Of course, I probably don’t cover all of them, but I cover at least the common ones.
Girls:
-Makes them feel mature and womanlike
-Can be used for practical reasons (regulating their period)
-Used as a means to have sex without parents finding out
-May be made more sexualized after taking it (ie labeled as “easy” or a “sure thing,” but usually more often than not it’s related to behavior)
-May make them less likely to stay abstinent, knowing there is a safety net
Boys:
-Increases their chances at having sex with girls their age
-Don’t have to worry about supplying their own protection
-May not affect their opinion of girls at all
Young Women (20s):
-Allows them to engage in sexual activities without the fear of getting pregnant
-Liberates them by enabling them to have “one-night stands”
-They can focus on their career or other priorities (means of reassurance)
Young Men (20s):
-Responsibility is out of their hands
-Have to trust that their partner is actually taking it, and won’t stop on purpose to try and get pregnant
-Perception of girls who are dating material vs girls who are good for one-night stands (not sure if birth control influences this as much as behavior, but it might)
Wives/Mothers:
-Allows them to mitigate the chances of them getting pregnant (if they don’t want any kids, maybe no more kids, or no kids during a certain portion of their career)
-Enables them to maintain sex lives with their husbands
-May be nervous about their daughter’s sexual activity once she goes on the pill
Fathers:
-Birth control benefits them by maintaining a sex life without fear of having more kids
-Has to trust that wife is taking it, and will not stop taking it if she wants more kids
-Can be supportive of daughter’s independence
-May become more strict on dating rules
Media: I think the media encourages such contraceptive methods and endorses these over others, such as abstinence.
Purveyors of Pop Culture (TV shows, Media, etc): From my experience, I think TV shows directed at teenagers romanticize the pill by emphasizing sexual freedom and the ability to have sex outside of parental knowledge of the act.
After re-reading, I’m not entirely sure if I answered the “characterized” questions right. I just outlined the assumptions/beliefs associated by each different stakeholder. May have to go back and edit.
5. What cultural narratives govern your artifact?
“One-night stands” – with such a trustworthy contraceptive method that women are in control of (instead of trusting that the partner has a condom), women are free to go out and sleep with a stranger, or perhaps a non-stranger, but not a monogamous partner, without being afraid of getting pregnant
“Friends with benefits” – may open other avenues of sexual engagement
Liberation of the female body – women are now free to choose how they want to use their bodies, since they do not have to worry about getting pregnant.
Liberation of women with careers – women do not have to worry about getting pregnant and needing to take maternity leave from their career, whether they are married or not
Risk of Stroke/Medical Precautions – there are many women who are cautious/wary of birth control and it’s side effects. While there is not enough statistical evidence to ward off women, there are those who prefer other contraceptive methods because they fear for their health/future ability to reproduce
“Decline of responsibility and sensibility” – There is a much quieter narrative regarding birth control that purveys the pill has allowed too much liberation in the sense that people aren’t making wise choices with who they have sex with anymore. They disdain the culture of one-night stands, and prefer monogamous relationships, or perhaps abstinence until marriage.
6. What assumptions, stereotypes, habits, social practices, and institutions frame your artifact?
Assumptions/Stereotypes (already referenced above, so I’ll denote them briefly):
- Women have more sex/more non-monogamous sex
- Men relinquish responsibility/control
Habits:
- One night stands/casual sex
Social Practices:
- More casual sex lives
- If married, more control on how many children to have (more families are having fewer and fewer children because of the economy)
- Women have the ability to maintain a longer career track if they so choose
Institutions: Health care, Public school (sex education), Planned Parenthood/other women health care institutions,
7. What doctrines or practices affect your artifact? (Or, what doctrines or practices you’re your artifact affect?) Political parties and platforms? Religious? Ideological? Which ones? Are there cultural “rules” and practices? Which?
The Catholic Church is against birth control of any types, although not all Catholics prescribe to that belief. There may be other religions who also frown on using birth control.
While the majority of Feminism supports birth control, not all feminists agree with it’s results/repercussions of an over-sexualized culture.
I feel that both political parties would support the use of birth control because it prevents abortions, although I feel that Democrats/Leftists may endorse it more than Republicans/Conservatives. But this is just an inference.
8. How does your artifact affect culture? How does culture affect your artifact?
Birth control affects culture because it opens up more opportunities for women, to say the least. Whether it directly affects their lives, through being able to have sex without fear of getting pregnant, or indirectly affects their lives, through being able to have more control over their career, how many kids they want (if any), the quality of their marriage, etc., birth control changes culture by enabling women to be more active players in society. Whether they are successful business women, or actresses, or simply following their passions, women are enabled to have more successful careers. This also changes their love/lust lives, because they can now engage in sexual activities as often as they want, and perhaps with a wider variety of people than one would if they were anxious about the possibility of getting pregnant.
I think culture affects the artifact through gender norms. It may inhibit the artifact, because although women have a means to stay in the workforce and not have kids if they desire, society pressures them into settling down and raising a family. I think the stereotypes and assumptions also shape birth control, because it labels women who do utilize it for whatever purpose, even if it has nothing to do with promiscuity.
After all of this, I’m not sure if I’m going to stick with birth control. It’s kind of boring, but maybe I’m just not looking at it right. I don’t know if I’d want to write a paper regurgitating all of that, and I can’t think of a unique spin. I’m just not sure what other interesting feminist artifacts there are that aren’t overdone…is alimony an artifact?